Best Mild Homemade Sauerkraut Recipe {That Happens to Be Super Easy, Too!}

Interested in the flavor and probiotic effect from homemade sauerkraut, but not dealing with crocks, burping, and mold? Try this easy and quick-to-mix sauerkraut recipe that’s as set-it-and-forget-it as they come!

Some links in this article are affiliate links and if you click on them I will receive a small commission at no cost to you.

Is it silly to be excited over sauerkraut? Probably – in fact I’d probably roll my eyes at the mention of a “homemade sauerkraut recipe” just a couple years ago. But that was before my deep dive into gut health and discovering that ‘fermented’ just meant pickled (not anything weird), only using salt to pickle with the resulting good-gut bugs instead of vinegar.

Between eating a few spoonfuls of fermented foods daily (both these cut vegetables and this yummy corn relish are staples now) and drinking warm lemon water each morning, my digestion issues that spurred the gut health research have pretty much disappeared completely. And that’s nothing to roll your eyes at, right?

After dipping my toes into fermenting with the veggies and corn relish – and seeing how easy it can be when you use these lids – I turned my goal to producing a sauerkraut we would love (well, I also experimented with my own kimchi, but that’s another story…). I figured it would be just like the others since it’s basically fermented cabbage, so it shouldn’t be hard.

And maybe “hard” isn’t the word I would use now, but it was certainly more complicated than I thought, which is why it’s taken me this long to test, tweak, and be able to publish this sauerkraut recipe – a full year after my last fermented recipe.

The thing with most sauerkraut recipes is they’ll say something like this:

“Ferment on your counter until done.”

Until done? What the heck does that mean to a fermenting newbie? I guess because actual sauerkraut (not the vinegar kraut you can buy canned in the stores) wasn’t part of our diet I had a harder time with this. I wasn’t even sure what it was supposed to taste like, other than pickled cabbage.

If the recipes didn’t say “until done” then they ranged everywhere from weeks to months of storage, which frankly wasn’t any help either. So the recipe testing began. Which mainly meant us figuring out what we liked because we learned fairly soon that you can have a strong tasting (and smelling) sauerkraut or a mild kraut. Guess which we preferred?

I tried ferments with lots of added ingredients like onions and hot peppers (we’re fans of spicy, it seemed like a good idea), and left them out for a month. Wayyyy too strong. I tried just cabbage and left it for 6 weeks. Whew, no.

In the end it was our trip to Leavenworth, Washington (a Bavarian inspired town) that finally steered us in the right direction to a sauerkraut that we loved. We bought a refrigerated, locally made product that was so good and mild that we could eat it with a fork from the jar. The ingredients were simply cabbage, salt, and water. And while my sauerkraut isn’t quite that spare, we realized that we prefer a mild product with barely a hint of pickling, just like the jar in Leavenworth.

So I’ve spent the last few months getting just the right ratio of ingredients, time fermenting on the counter, and time in the fridge, to create what I think is the best homemade sauerkraut recipe.

The even better part? Using the Easy Fermenter Lids like my last two recipes takes all the issues with homemade sauerkraut out of the equation! It’s simply a matter of mixing it up, packing it in a jar, adding the lid and then leaving it to work it’s magic with no more work on your part at all.

Pretty cool, right? Let’s make some!

How to Make Homemade Sauerkraut

Step 1: Dump your shredded cabbage into a large bowl.

I’m going to start with a confession: I used to buy a head of cabbage and shred it myself, but now I just buy a couple bags of shredded cabbage (or coleslaw mix with carrots and purple cabbage like pictured). At .99 to $1.30 each, the price is similar and the time savings is worth it to me!

Also, some people only ferment with organic produce, but that would make this pretty expensive and cabbage is always on the “clean 15” list for pesticides, so I stick with the more cost effective version. You do you.

TIP: I always shred one peeled apple into the mix because I read that it helps keep the sauerkraut mild. It’s optional of course.

Step 2: Add the other ingredients and stir and press together.

Use a potato masher (or a cabbage pounder if you’re fancy like that) to press and mash the cabbage as you stir it for a good 2-4 minutes. You should see it start to break down and release a bit of juice.

Step 3: Let cabbage mixture rest for 30 minutes.

At the end of the resting time, the mixture should be one-third to one-half the volume of where it started, like pictured above. There will be anywhere from a couple teaspoons to a couple tablespoons of liquid at the bottom.

Step 4: Pack cabbage mixture into a wide-mouth mason jar and attach lid.

Use a wooden spoon (or that cabbage pounder) to press the cabbage down firmly as you add it to the jar, removing as much air as you can. Some liquid will be visible, but it won’t cover the cabbage, so add a bit of room-temperature water (filtered if you’re on city water) to just slightly cover the top of the cabbage (about 1/2-inch).

Set a glass weight on top to keep the cabbage under the liquid (I really want to get these, since I’m tired of fishing out the slippery regular weights with my fingers) and screw on an Easy Fermenter Lid. Move the dial on the top to the day of the month.

TIP: I also add a sticky note to the side with the date I need to put it in the fridge and the date it will be ready so I don’t have to think about it later.

Note: Sometimes the liquid gets absorbed in the first couple of days and the cabbage is exposed to air. You’ll notice that the top of the cabbage is starting to discolor a bit. Remove the lid and weight, stir up the cabbage, and press down again. Add more water to cover, replace weight and lid. There is a large syringe-type tool included in the Easy Fermenter Lid kit and this is when you’d use it (or anytime you open the lids on a ferment for some reason). Hold it over the center air lock and pump the air out one time. You’ll feel a give and if you try and pump again, there shouldn’t be any air left.

Step 5: Wait “until it’s done.”

Ha! Just kidding. Leave on the counter 2 weeks, take off the fermenting lid and replace with a mason jar storage lid and put the jar in the refrigerator for 1 week.

I’ve found this timing to give us the best, mild homemade sauerkraut, though you could taste test it at the 2-week mark to see if you’d like it then. The week in cold storage seems to temper it just a bit more for our tastes. And believe it or not, this is a quick sauerkraut recipe!

Step 6: Eat and enjoy.

Some people have asked how we eat sauerkraut (no, we’re not eating sausages everyday…). Here are some of our favorite ways to enjoy this fermented cabbage recipe:

• Topping a salad.
• Next to any kind of grilled or roasted meat or poultry.
• On a sandwich, especially grilled paninis made with roast beef.
• Topping pulled pork, alone or in sandwiches or tortillas.
• As a Tex-Mex condiment, especially pork or fish tacos.
• On top of a Triscuit cracker (surprisingly good).
• Right out of the jar!

Click the arrow for the full homemade sauerkraut recipe (with print options)!

Subscribe & Get Simple Real Food Dinner Menus + Shopping Lists

Subscribe to AOC's popular weekly Newsletter full of useful information, behind-the-scenes updates, and occasional offers AND get access to this Seasonal Menu Ebook with 20 weeks of dinner menu ideas in the VIP Subscriber Library! The Library also includes notebooks, checklists, organizing helps, and recipes - with more added regularly. We'll never send spam - read our Privacy Policy here.

Welcome - I'm so glad you've joined the AOC community! Your first step is to check your email to confirm your subscription and you'll be on your way to your free eBook and more printables.

There was an error submitting your subscription. Please try again.

First Name

Email Address

We use this field to detect spam bots. If you fill this in, you will be marked as a spammer.

I'd like to receive the free email course. I want simple dinner ideas! Unsubscribe at any time. Powered by ConvertKit