Easy step-by-step recipe for honey caramel corn – no corn syrup or thermometers needed! AND how to turn it into homemade “Moose Munch” by adding chocolate to half, making it a perfect gift or party food for holidays – or any days.
Some links in this article are affiliate links and if you click on them I will receive a small commission at no cost to you.
This recipe for homemade caramel corn is made with honey instead of corn syrup and is super easy to make – but everyone will think you slaved away! I found the original corn-syrup version of the caramel corn recipe in a vintage Farm Journal cookbook inherited from Brian’s Kansas grandma, but I knew it was worth adapting because of the 5-minute cooking time – and great results.
And when I turned the caramel corn into a Harry & David Moose Munch knock-off, it became the most popular Christmas treat we give to our family and friends. To make it as close to the H&D version we liked so much, I figured out how to thoroughly coat some of the caramel corn with chocolate, and then mix them so you’d be able to pick out the different caramel or chocolate corn from a bowl (versus just drizzling caramel corn with chocolate). And it is SO good.
I had to share it with you for two reasons:
- Everyone tells me their family fights over this Moose Munch popcorn and they have to make sure it’s equally distributed to keep the peace.
- I can only make this one time a year or I will eat it all in a sitting, a-hem.
Anything that good deserves a place in the Christmas line-up, right?
Update: Or birthday line-up! It’s so loved that I’ve given it away as birthday gifts so no sharing is needed.
Since some people shy away from making caramel corn (you know, hot syrup, candy thermometers and all that), I’m going to walk you through the steps so you can see how easy it is- really.
Here are two things you won’t find in my recipe:
- corn syrup
- candy thermometers
So now there really are no excuses. Except for all the sugar and butter part, but we won’t bother about that right now, okay?
Timeline for Gifting or Serving
To make the Moose Munch for a gift, you’ll need to make the caramel corn recipe and let it cool completely. Then one half will be coated with melted chocolate and that will have to cool completely before mixing the two back together, which takes many hours (I leave it overnight). So you’ll need to plan to make this a few days before serving or gifting.
Supplies Used to Make Honey Caramel Corn & Moose Munch Variation:
- Popcorn Air Popper (make sure to get one with an on-off switch)
- Large Roasting Pan
- Quality Popcorn
- White & Brown Sugar
- Honey
- 4-quart Saucepan
- Wooden Spoon
- Large Stainless Steel Spoon
- Waxed Paper or Parchment Paper
- Semi-Sweet, Bittersweet, Milk Chocolate, or Baking Chocolate (or White Chocolate for Peppermint Crunch variation)
- Large Clear Gift Baggies
Easily Make Honey Caramel Corn
Prepare the Popcorn
1. Pop the popcorn. I use an air popper because it’s easy. You can make it however you wish.
2. Then spread it in a large, oiled roasting pan. The most important thing to remember, though, about this step is to leave all the unpopped and partially popped kernels in the bowl when you transfer the popcorn to the pan. Do this by transferring the popcorn with a your hands or a spoon, not just dumping it into the pan. Your teeth (and your family’s teeth) will thank you.
3. Set the pan of popcorn in a 250 degree oven to warm while making the caramel.
Make the Easy Honey Caramel Coating
4. Place the butter, sugars, and honey in a large saucepan set over medium heat to melt it together. TIP: Use a wooden spoon at this point so it can stay in the pan during the cooking process and not get hot.
5. Stir until you start to see some gentle bubbles on the surface, similar to the picture top left (I really tried to get a picture of this, but the light and camera weren’t cooperating, though I think it’s close).
6. When you see the gentle bubbles, set a timer for 5 minutes.
7. Continue to stir for the full 5 minutes. The mixture will start boiling a bit harder, but never get crazy on you, similar to the photo on the top right.
TIP: I always make the caramel in a large 4-qt. saucepan to give it all the room it might need. I have had no spits or overflows with this recipe, though you should take care because it’s hot and will burn at this point (not that you wouldn’t have figured that out – I just want to cover all the bases).
8. When the timer goes off (see? no thermometer!) remove the pan of popcorn from the oven and pour the caramel mixture over the popped corn. Mix with a large stainless steel spoon in the pan until most of the popcorn is evenly coated.
9. Place the pan in the oven. Bake for 15 minutes, stir the pan of caramel corn again and then return to the oven for another 10-15 minutes. Prep a counter space with two large pieces of waxed paper or parchment.
10. Immediately pour the hot caramel corn onto the waxed paper, spreading it out over the paper to cool. Cool completely, and then break into as small pieces as possible.
Ta-da, you’ve made the easiest honey caramel corn! You seriously won’t believe how good this is and how simple to make.
You can use it just like this – a wonderful caramel corn – or you can take half of it and coat it with chocolate for a homemade version of Harry & David’s Moose Munch gourmet popcorn (for a LOT less!).
Make Honey Caramel Corn into Moose Munch
1. Divide the cooled caramel corn in half. Place one half in an airtight container. Place the other half in a large bowl.
2. Melt 12 oz. of chocolate chips (you can use any chocolate you’d like: milk, semi-sweet, or dark chocolate or even a combination), pour over the caramel corn in the bowl and mix thoroughly until most of the corn is coated. NEW Variation: I’ve also made this into “Peppermint Crunch Caramel Corn” by coating the caramel corn with quality white chocolate and sprinkling crushed candy canes over it while the chocolate is still wet so it sticks.
3. Spread the chocolate-covered caramel corn back onto the waxed paper and use a couple of forks to separate the pieces as much as you can so that it will be easier to distribute the chocolate corn with the plain caramel corn.
4. Let it sit until hardened completely (I usually let it sit overnight, covered with plastic or wax paper).
5. When the chocolate is firm, mix it together with the plain caramel corn and package it up in baggies or containers.
I recommend that you bag it up as fast as you can.
How long does this honey caramel corn keep?
I have made this weeks in advance of gifting and it’s been fine kept in airtight bags at room temperature. Surprisingly, this also freezes well – I found out by accident after storing a goodie bag full of cookies and Moose Munch in the freezer when we couldn’t deliver it. It was all perfect when defrosted.
I hope you and your loved ones enjoy this recipe as much as we have!
Click the arrow for the full honey caramel corn recipe (with print options)!
Subscribe & Get Simple Real Food Dinner Menus + Shopping Lists
Subscribe to AOC's popular weekly Newsletter full of useful information, behind-the-scenes updates, and occasional offers AND get access to this Seasonal Menu Ebook with 20 weeks of dinner menu ideas in the VIP Subscriber Library! The Library also includes notebooks, checklists, organizing helps, and recipes - with more added regularly. We'll never send spam - read our Privacy Policy here.
Jermey says
This is a perfect recipe. I made it and it was amazing. Thanks for sharing
Jami says
Glad to hear it!
Kathy Thomas says
Dear Jami, to save time , would it be possible to use already popped bags of popcorn and continue on with the recipe. Will be busy and am having a group of about 15 over Thrusday for movie night. We will be watching “War Room” I think. This sounds like a nice treat.
May God bless you for your honesty and your wonderful recipies. I have dropped 40 pounds.
Warmest Regards from Va.,
Kathy
Jami says
I haven’t, but I’m sure it would, Kathy – as long as there’s not a lot of salt or “butter” flavor (that may make it taste off). And congrats on your weight loss – that’s FANTASTIC!! Did you do it with real food and moderation?
ramona says
If I was to add nuts to the mix when would be the best time to add them?
Jami says
With the popcorn, before you mix in the caramel mixture, would be best I think, Ramona.
Debbie says
I think it can be done with so many new products they have now. Especially sugar free dark chocolate by Dove!
Debbie says
Can you make the moose munch sugar free? Being diabetic it would be wonderful!!
Jami says
Lol ๐
Kate L. says
This recipe was exactly what I was looking for! Though I have no problem with using a candy thermometer, I loved that there was no corn syrup (and I have to admit not using a candy thermometer was kind of nice) and I loved the overall flavor and texture. I ended up adding some mixed nuts to mine and the extra salty kick made it perfect ๐
Jami says
I’d love to add nuts, but I’m too cheap when I’m making huge batches to give away. ๐ Maybe I’ll have to make a small batch with nuts just for us!
Andrea says
Hello! I was wondering if you
Knew how much 2/3 c unpopped popcorn is when popped? I would like to use the popcorn you microwave in the bags-will that work? Trying to figure out howamy bags I need..thanks!
Jami says
Hmmm, Andrea, I know that 1/2 c. unpopped yields about 8-10 cups, so 12-14 cups from 2/3?
Anonymous says
I just made the caramel popcorn- not so good! This was my first attempt at making popcorn on the stove. It tastes like oil. I used about 3 tablespoons of oil for the 2/3 cup of popcorn. Was that too much? I think I need to start over!! I also used dark brown sugar as that is all I had. Is that ok? Thanks!! I’m sure your recipe is good….I just need to practice making popcorn on the stove!! ๐
Jami @ An Oregon Cottage says
I’ve only used air-popped popcorn, so I haven’t had that problem with the caramel corn. When I’ve made popcorn on the stove I don’t measure- I just put in a bit of oil (not 3TB though- that seems too much) and a layer of kernels on the bottom of the pot. There only needs to be enough oil for the seeds to barely sit in.
Hope that helps!
Jami @An Oregon Cottage says
Katie- Yes, I found that men universally love this stuff. ๐ Valentine’s is a great idea- I’ve gifted it to a couple of my brothers-in-law for their b-days and it was most appreciated!
-Jami
Katie says
This is my boyfriend’s “favorite snack ever”…I think I’ll make it for him as a Valentine’s treat! Thanks!
Jami @An Oregon Cottage says
Robin-Thanks for the comment! I found that the baking soda made the caramel corn more grainy (not sure how to describe it- a texture that was different from the store-bought caramel corn), so I leave it out for that reason. Vanilla is good- sometimes I think to put it in, but most times I don’t. ๐ Honestly, I can’t tell a difference, but I know I’m not refined that way. ๐
Sure you can feature the recipe with a link! I appreciate it (and you’re asking!). Have a merry holiday!
Robin says
This looks awesome-I have made Baked Caramel Corn for years-the whole time my kids were growing up-I find this one really different in a nice way-I think it might be time to change it up a bit this year. My recipe is very similar-pretty much the same ingredients, just different amounts. After getting your good boil on the caramel sauce-if you stir in 1/2 t. of baking soda and 1 t. vanilla–the caramel sauce puffs up and turns super creamy-pour it on corn right away. I have a site called HomeComforts-could I add your link and recipe for this coming week? Love your site–used to live in Hillsboro-just outside of Portland. Oregon is the best place-loved it there. Thanks
Jami @An Oregon Cottage says
Rachael- Yes, that is perfect etiquette- good job, and thank you! I’m glad you enjoyed the recipe- I’ll have to try coconut sugar- does it have a coconut flavor? We really don’t like coconut flavor in things unless it’s a coconut treat, so I’ve had to be pretty careful about what I use the oil in.
And I’m going to have to make some of the Tiger Bark- yu-um!
Rachael @ GratefullyNourished says
Coconut sugar does not have a coconut flavor, it tastes a little more like brown sugar (and acts a little more like it as well). I have the same issue with using coconut in things that aren’t supposed to taste coconutty, but I haven’t had any problems using the sugar.
Jami @ An Oregon Cottage says
That’s good to know, Rachael- thanks! I’ve been hesitant to try it, ’cause its expensive and I didn’t know what the flavor would be like. Now to find a deal on it. ๐
Rachael Resurreccion @ gratefullynourished says
I made this yesterday and loved it! We put it in our Christmas gift basket. I linked to your recipe in my recent blog post:
http://www.gratefullynourished.com/gratefully-nourished/2011/12/12/gift-baskets-and-tiger-butter.html
I’m new at this, so I hope this is okay (still figuring out blog etiquette and all). Thank you!
Jami @An Oregon Cottage says
Kelly- Easier? Do share!! And I suppose you could use the almond bark, but since it’s not real chocolate, the flavor won’t be as good…it’s up to you. ๐
Kelly says
Ooops–forgot to ask a quick question….Do you think this would work with melted almond bark in place of the chocolate chips? I have some leftover from last Christmas and was thinking I could use it up in this. What do you think?? Thanks!
Kelly says
This looks so good! I have a caramel corn recipe that is even easier than yours. I’m going to have to make some & then add the chocolate. What a great gift idea–I’m thinking of making a batch or 2 and leave in the teachers’ lounge as a *thank you* to all the teachers who keep me busy subbing for them! Thanks for sharing!
Honey @ Sunflower Schoolhouse says
That looks really yummy. I am sure it would not last long around our house.
Jami @An Oregon Cottage says
What?! You’ve moved from Southern Oregon, Heather? Never say! ๐ Ahh, but ocean shores, huh? Not bad at all- Hope you’re enjoying it!
Heather's Blog-o-rama says
That stuff is addicting ๐ ๐ I used to buy a well-known name brand. This recipe looks really, really good ๐ ๐ Love and hugs from the ocean shores of California (formerly Oregon), Heather ๐