Quick Honey Sweetened Homemade Ketchup Recipe

Yes, you CAN make homemade ketchup with honey – and sweetened ONLY with a little honey – that your family will love. Plus, it’s made in just minutes with basic pantry staples – this is going to become a go-to recipe for you!

You can find more great recipes like this on the Quick Healthy Recipes page.

Some links in this article are affiliate links and if you click on them and purchase I will receive a small commission at no cost to you.

This recipe is one of AOC’s Pantry Basic series – basic foods you can find in almost everyone’s pantries that we buy from the store, thinking (like I did!) that they can’t be made at home. But I’ve found they are not only simple and cheaper to make at home, they are actually better tasting – and of course better for you because you get to be the one to decide the ingredients.

Homemade ketchup (and other recipes I call “pantry basics“) was one of the first recipes I published when I started AOC back in 2009. The recipe was a revelation to me – it tasted great, I loved how easy it was to make our own ketchup, AND I could control the ingredients. You can imagine why I rushed to get it up on the site, I was so excited to share the recipe!

So, what’s the big deal about buying ketchup?

When I started making this easy homemade ketchup, options other than major store brands weren’t available. If there were organic brands, they were prohibitively expensive.

Now that there are more affordable organic options in stores, I still choose to make our own ketchup for these reasons:

1. I can make it with less sweetener (even organic brands often have the same amount of sugar – about 4 grams sugar per tablespoon, similar to a small chocolate chip cookie!).
2. I can choose the type of sweetener (honey, maple syrup, brown sugar, etc.).
3. It still is cheaper to make it (around $2 for almost 3 cups).
4. It takes about 5 minutes hands-on time.

That last point has actually saved me many times as the family was looking forward to the burgers that were grilling or pigs in blankets that were baking and I realized we were out of ketchup. But I always have tomato paste, vinegar, and honey, so I can whip up a batch in no time.

And that 15-20 minute simmering time? Well, I’m here to say you can push that to ten minutes or even five and still get good ketchup!

I’ve experimented with adaptations a lot over the years, using less brown sugar, trying maple syrup, and then honey, and always seeing how low I could go on the sugar and still make my family happy.

In the end, it’s this version sweetened only with 1/3 to 1/2 cup of honey that hit the sweet spot (pun intended!). Honey is sweeter tasting than processed sugar, so you can generally use less of it in recipes like this. I started with 3/4 cup and then found we could go lower still.

And easy? Here’s a video I made to show you just how easy:

Homemade Ketchup Recipe

For this easy ketchup recipe you’ll need these pantry staples:

• apple cider vinegar
• tomato paste (Only one can is pictured, you’ll need two 6 ounce or one 12 ounce for a full recipe.)
• 1/3 to 1/2 cup honey (I usually use 1/2 cup measure and fill it slightly less.)
• salt
• garlic powder
• onion powder
• optional cinnamon and/or allspice (I don’t use these, but I know some people like them in ketchup.)

Starting with tomato paste is what makes this recipe quick. (TIP: tomato paste should have one ingredient – tomatoes. If your paste has more ingredients, start buying a different brand.) If you were to start with canned tomatoes or even fresh tomatoes, you’d be looking at hours of cooking to get the ketchup thick enough.

For storing you’ll also need:

• Stainless Steel Funnel for pouring hot ketchup into bottle – (this is the set of 3 stainless funnels I have – I don’t recommend plastic with hot foods)
• 16 ounce Glass Storage Bottles – I always get asked about the cute bottle pictured that I use for our ketchup – it’s many years old (back when Martha Stewart had a line at Kmart!) and I haven’t found anything exactly like it. However, here is a set of nice bottles that come with labels (gift idea!), and these swing-top square bottles would be fun. Also, this site has a lot of glass bottle options you may like.

How to Make Ketchup

Like I mentioned, it’s super simple to throw this together – just dump all the ingredients in a medium sized saucepan, bring to a boil and then turn to low to simmer for 15 to 20 minutes (or what ever time you have until dinner, a-hem).

The one thing you’ll need to be careful with is spitting ketchup during the simmering stage. While it doesn’t need any hands-on time other than a stir mid-way through the simmer, you will need to protect you and your stovetop from the hot bubbling, spitting ketchup. 

To do this, I’ve found it easiest to place a wooden spoon in the pot (metal gets too hot) and then balance the lid on it so there’s an opening for air and moisture, but the spitting bubbles are contained. The reason you don’t want the lid on completely is to allow the ketchup to thicken by cooking down some.

Once it’s simmered, cool the ketchup a bit, testing to make sure it’s the consistency you like, and use the metal funnel to carefully pour it into a glass bottle. Store in the refrigerator like you do store bought ketchup.

Ketchup Recipe FAQ

How long does homemade ketchup last?

So here’s where I’m going to tell you what I can find as the recommended time to keep homemade ketchup in the refrigerator: one month. 

And here’s where I’m going to tell you how long our ketchup lasts in the fridge: as long as we need it to. Which sometimes means a month, but often longer. I’m not sure how this would go “bad” with all the vinegar and ours certainly hasn’t.

So, yeah, I’ll leave that up to you. Make a half batch if you’re not sure how quickly you’ll use it, or freeze half.

Can you water-bath can this ketchup?

I’ve gotten this question often. No, this hasn’t been tested for canning safely, so it’s for refrigeration or freezing only. I can say that I don’t think it would ever be safe for water-bath canning since it’s so thick and a tomato product. Someone with know-how would have to test for pressure canning – and that’s not me, I’m a water-bath girl.

Whenever I adapt a recipe to use a different sweetener, I always get questions about what the original ingredients were, so I’ll just get that out of the way now: all the ingredients are the same, except the sweetener was 1 cup of brown or white sugar, or a combo. Quite a difference, right?

Should you adapt family favorite recipes?

Making family favorite recipes healthier is always one of my goals when cooking. I know some people have a “don’t mess with it” mindset, but I’m more of a “why not see if there’s a difference” type of person.

If there is a marked difference and we don’t like the new version, I go back. But what harm is there in experimenting? You may have one not-as-good recipe or you may have a new sort of life changing way to enjoy it, like this ketchup!

Our whole family still loves this ketchup with honey, and my kids continue to douse their food in it (teens and ketchup…) with no grumblings about any changes. That’s a good thing, right?

What about other sweeteners?

I have used maple syrup, but didn’t care for the flavor in this recipe as much as honey. But definitely experiment if you’d like to! I fount that since it’s less sweet than honey, I needed to use about 2/3 of a cup to the 12 ounces of tomato paste.

I tried coconut sugar, too. My family really didn’t care for it – there was a distinct flavor and it wasn’t very sweet, even with the 2/3 cup I used.

I haven’t tried others and don’t use sugar substitutes, so can’t speak for them. Since this is thickened with the paste, it is easy to experiment with because the sugar is mainly for flavor. Try what you’d like and see how it turns out! 

Print

This recipe has been updated – it was originally published in March of 2009.

Other pantry basics you may like:

 

Homemade Chocolate Syrup Recipe

 

4 Vinaigrette Salad Dressings from 1 Basic Recipe

 

Easy Slow Cooker Chicken Broth

 
Disclosure: affiliate links in this article will earn commission based on sales, but it doesn’t change your price. Click here to read my full disclaimer and advertising disclosure.